In short: A marketplace brings buyers who are already searching. Your own online shop gives you control over brand, customer relationships and margins, but you have to bring every visitor yourself. Most small businesses do best with both: start where the buyers are and build the shop alongside.
The two models compared
| Question | Marketplace | Own online shop |
| How fast can I start? | Within days: create an account, list products | Weeks: set up shop, payment, legal texts |
| Where do buyers come from? | They are already there and searching | You pay for or earn every visitor |
| What does it cost? | Fees per listing, per sale or per month | Shop software, payment fees, marketing |
| Who owns the customer relationship? | Largely the marketplace | You |
| How free am I? | Bound by the marketplace's rules and changes | Your own rules, your own design |
| Why should buyers trust me? | The marketplace lends trust: checks, payment protection, reviews | You have to build it yourself |
When a marketplace is the better choice
- You are starting out and nobody knows your brand yet.
- You sell one-off items, used goods or changing stock.
- Your products are searched for by name or type, such as machines, spare parts or vehicles.
- You want to test a new product or a new country without building anything first.
When your own shop pays off
- Customers come back regularly and you want to address them directly.
- Your brand and presentation are part of the value.
- You have the time and budget to bring visitors through search, advertising or a newsletter.
- Your margins are too thin for marketplace commissions at higher volumes.
Doing both
Many sellers use marketplaces to be found and their own shop for repeat customers. A few rules keep this manageable:
- One stock list. Keep quantities in sync so that nothing is sold twice. Imports from a file or a shop connection help.
- Consistent information. The same titles, photos and specifications everywhere.
- Know your numbers per channel. Revenue, fees, returns and time spent.
- Respect the rules. Marketplaces usually do not allow you to steer buyers away from the platform during a sale.
How to compare the costs
Calculate the same month for each channel:
- Fixed costs: subscription or shop software, hosting, tools
- Costs per sale: commission, payment fees, shipping subsidies
- Costs to be found: advertising, highlighted listings, content
- Your time: listing, customer service, returns
Divide the total by the number of sales. A shop with low fees can still be more expensive per sale if visitors have to be bought.
Selling to businesses
For business customers, other things count: net prices, quotes on request, volume discounts, delivery terms and invoices with VAT details. Check whether a channel supports inquiries and negotiated prices, not just a shopping cart.
A short decision aid
- Fewer than a few dozen products, no brand yet: start on a marketplace.
- Established brand, repeat customers: own shop, with marketplaces as an additional channel.
- Expensive single items for businesses: specialised or B2B marketplaces plus direct sales.
Selling on Vermittco
On Vermittco, businesses and private sellers list in many categories. Buyers can purchase directly, send a non-binding inquiry or make a price proposal. Existing catalogues can be brought in by file import or a shop connection. Costs are listed under Pricing and fees, the steps under For sellers.
Frequently asked questions
Is a marketplace cheaper than an online shop?
Can I sell on a marketplace and in my own shop at the same time?
What is the biggest risk of selling only on marketplaces?
As of November 2026 · Publisher: Vermittco · All guides